ok so I'm really stupid and i just noticed that the reason hiccup loses his foot is because it is in the pedal thing he has attacked to Toothless and it gets ripped off when he falls off of toothless, because his new "foot" fits into it so well, like wat. i am so stupid yeah i had to tell someone form the fandom. weeeee.
there’s this giant debate about that at my school
did his foot rip off
or did toothless bite it off trying to catch him